Quick Verdict

For small to medium-sized teams with limited budget, Checkly is a more cost-effective option with a gentler learning curve, while larger enterprises with complex monitoring needs may prefer New Relic Synthetics for its robust feature set and scalability. Ultimately, the choice depends on your team’s specific requirements and scripting needs. If scripting is a top priority, Checkly’s more flexible and user-friendly approach might be the better fit.

Feature Comparison Table

When to Choose New Relic Synthetics

• If you’re a large enterprise with complex monitoring needs and a dedicated team for monitoring, New Relic Synthetics might be the better choice due to its robust feature set and scalability.
• If you’re already invested in the New Relic ecosystem and want to leverage its APM and infrastructure monitoring capabilities, New Relic Synthetics is a natural fit.
• If you have a team of experienced monitoring professionals who can handle the steep learning curve, New Relic Synthetics offers advanced features like custom dashboards and alerts.
• For example, if you’re a 200-person enterprise with a dedicated monitoring team and a budget of $50,000/month, New Relic Synthetics might be the better choice.

When to Choose Checkly

• If you’re a small to medium-sized team with limited budget and resources, Checkly is a more cost-effective option with a gentler learning curve.
• If you need robust scripting capabilities and custom monitoring solutions, Checkly’s flexible scripting approach makes it the better choice.
• If you’re looking for a more user-friendly interface and intuitive documentation, Checkly is a better fit for teams without extensive monitoring experience.
• For instance, if you’re a 20-person SaaS company with a budget of $5,000/month and need to monitor a simple API, Checkly might be the better choice.

Real-World Use Case: Monitoring

Let’s say you’re a 50-person e-commerce company needing to monitor your website’s API and browser performance. With New Relic Synthetics, setup complexity would take around 2-3 days, with an ongoing maintenance burden of 2-3 hours/week. The cost breakdown for 100 users/actions would be around $1,500/month. With Checkly, setup complexity would take around 1-2 days, with an ongoing maintenance burden of 1-2 hours/week. The cost breakdown for 100 users/actions would be around $290/month. Common gotchas include underestimating the complexity of custom scripting and not accounting for additional costs like data storage and support.

Migration Considerations

If switching between these tools, consider the following:

• Data export/import limitations: New Relic Synthetics has more restrictive data export policies, while Checkly offers more flexible data import and export options.
• Training time needed: New Relic Synthetics requires significant training and expertise, while Checkly has a gentler learning curve.
• Hidden costs: New Relic Synthetics may incur additional costs for custom scripting, data storage, and support, while Checkly’s pricing model is more transparent.

FAQ

Q: Which tool is better for scripting and custom monitoring solutions? A: Checkly is the better choice for scripting and custom monitoring solutions due to its robust scripting capabilities and flexible approach.

Q: Can I use both New Relic Synthetics and Checkly together? A: Yes, you can use both tools together, but it may require additional configuration and scripting to integrate them seamlessly. Checkly’s API and webhooks make it easier to integrate with other tools.

Q: Which has better ROI for Monitoring? A: Checkly has a better ROI for monitoring due to its lower costs and more flexible pricing model. Over a 12-month period, Checkly can save you around $10,000 compared to New Relic Synthetics, assuming a similar feature set and usage.

Bottom Line: For most teams, Checkly is the better choice for monitoring due to its cost-effectiveness, gentle learning curve, and robust scripting capabilities, making it an ideal solution for small to medium-sized teams with limited budget and resources.

🔍 More New Relic Synthetics Comparisons

Explore all New Relic Synthetics alternatives or check out Checkly reviews.